Sunday 26

Newcastle United

Was Carroll a gamble worth taking?

11th September 2019, 14:03 by Neil Foster

Newcastle’s Andy Carroll has started light training as he bids for yet another comeback but why would any manager want to sign such an injury-plagued player?

Football has been littered with injury-prone players over the years who have earned the moniker ‘sicknote’, with Tottenham and England midfielder Darren Anderton one of the more high profile names to fit that bill.

Now 47, the talented forward won 30 England caps but would have received many more had he not spent so much time in the treatment room.

The baton has now passed to Carroll, who seems to be taking it to another level and it remains to be seen when he will make his debut for the Magpies in his second stint on Tyneside.

In seven years with West Ham, the 30-year-old from Gateshead appeared in only 126 Premier League games – coming off the bench in many of them.

The rangy striker played 39 times for Newcastle in the Championship during the 2009-2010 campaign, earning him a move to Liverpool and he was a regular fixture in the Reds first team in 2011-12, with 35 outings.

However, that has not been the norm since and fans will be waiting for him to break down once again if and when he pulls on the black and white shirt.

The general consensus is that Steve Bruce signed up the free agent to get the supporters on board after his controversial appointment, as one of their own was returning to the club, but he cannot do much on the physio’s couch.

There is always the hope that Carroll will finally rid himself of the injuries that have blighted his career – but it seems unlikely.

The man capped nine times by England took tentative steps back into training on Tuesday but Bruce did not seem overly confident that the forward will be blazing a trail anytime soon.

“Now, we’ve got to progress that and see where he is but it’s calculating a gamble,” he said. “It’s a gamble I’m convinced after seeing him that he’ll take some part somewhere and if we can hopefully get him on the pitch then great.”

Signing a player with Carroll’s history of injuries is more than a gamble and smacks of desperation as there are many managers who would not go near someone who rarely plays.

However, after all that has gone on at Newcastle over the past few years, nothing is surprising any more.

This article originated on sportinastorm.com

Neil Foster is an experienced journalist who specialises in cricket and rugby union. Neil also has a solid knowledge of tennis, golf and football.

More Newcastle United

Newcastle United

Frustrated Newcastle boss Bruce rues replay after Oxford stalemate

26th January 2020, 09:41

Newcastle manager Steve Bruce has revealed his frustration after his plans for a winter break were hit by the need for an FA Cup replay against Oxford United.

Newcastle United

Newcastle United 0-0 Oxford United

25th January 2020, 19:12

Newcastle were left frustrated as they were held to a goalless draw by a resilient Oxford United side in their FA Cup fourth-round clash at St James' Park.

Newcastle United

Magpies still have pulling power in the market – Bruce

25th January 2020, 11:19

Steve Bruce is convinced Newcastle's successful double swoop for loan signings Nabil Bentaleb and Valentino Lazaro proves the club still has pulling power.

Newcastle United

Lazaro “very happy” to make temporary Newcastle switch

24th January 2020, 17:24

Newcastle United have made their second signing of the January transfer window after confirming the arrival of Valentino Lazaro on loan.

Newcastle United

Newcastle United v Oxford United Team News

24th January 2020, 13:27

Steve Bruce says he will field a strong Newcastle side against League One Oxford in the FA Cup fourth round with loan signing Nabil Bentaleb set for his debut.

Newcastle United

Newcastle sign former Tottenham midfielder Bentelab on loan

21st January 2020, 14:43

Newcastle United have confirmed they have signed Nabil Bentaleb on loan until the end of the season, with an option to make the deal permanent.

Recent Sport Headlines


Rahm secures Farmers Insurance Open lead

26th January 2020, 12:00

Spaniard Jon Rahm fired home a seven-under 65 to secure the lead ahead of the final round of the Farmers Insurance Open.

Manchester City

Guardiola explains tough challenge for City to find Aguero replacement

26th January 2020, 11:49

Manchester City boss Pep Guardiola has admitted the club have a mighty job on their hands to find a long-term replacement for Sergio Aguero at the Etihad.

Rugby League

Burrell ready to silence his critics

26th January 2020, 11:02

Warrington Wolves centre Luther Burrell is confident he has finally adapted to rugby league after his summer switch in 2019.


Lampard demands Blues improvement after stuttering cup display

26th January 2020, 10:47

Chelsea boss Frank Lampard knows his side must do better after they were made to battle to a 2-1 victory over Hull City on Saturday.

Rugby League

Smith happy to give youngsters a go

26th January 2020, 10:19

Hull KR coach Tony Smith has confirmed the younger members of his squad will be given a chance to impress against Wakefield Trinity.

Tottenham Hotspur

Spurs star Winks learning to battle through the pain

26th January 2020, 10:11

Tottenham midfielder Harry Winks admits he is still learning how to manage and play through his troublesome ankle injury.


Kenin gets the better of Gauff

26th January 2020, 10:07

American teenager Coco Gauff is out of the Australian Open after Sofia Kenin battled back to secure her place in the quarter-finals.

Newcastle United

Frustrated Newcastle boss Bruce rues replay after Oxford stalemate

26th January 2020, 09:41

Newcastle manager Steve Bruce has revealed his frustration after his plans for a winter break were hit by the need for an FA Cup replay against Oxford United.